They're all over the place. You just have to adapt your search to LI pricing. You'll be hard pressed to find anything decent (that's within a reasonable commuting distance) for under $425k, and more realistically upper 4's or lower 5's. My house is new construction but it's not what I would call fancy at all. colonial, the garage is to small to fit a car, the driveway can't fit 2 cars side by side, and it's a busy streetWow. With the discount, crazy. New construction too - nice. I’ve looked around for new builds. They seem hard to find in Suffolk Co.