MHBP consumer hdhp is cheaper and better than BCBS.
This take considers money spent on healthcare for a self plus 1 or family. Single is tricky and the risk/reward margin is much thinner.
Consider this.
$4k deductible. $2400 yearly contribution from the plan into your HSA. That's a $1600 net deductible. The difference in premiums is more than $1600/year.
Simple math, the numbers are presented to you by the OPM. It's less expensive.
Pros: copays are lower. Aetna website is very user friendly. Providers are easy to find in my area. HSA is a retirement savings powerhouse. It also allows for a couple unique strategies to lower taxable income if you don't have the money to Max out the HSA contributions for a given year.
Cons: prescription drugs are not as straightforward. You're pretty much locked in to CVS from what I can tell and the 90 day scripts are cheaper than the 30 day scripts. (Hardly a problem for me, but I don't know what drugs your family takes) Mail order drugs aren't possibly in this plan if I remember right.
Honestly my memory of prescription drugs on this plan is shaky, look into it yourself. Use the resources to see what your drug costs will be.