Your strawman argument seems to be that since NATCA does not control conduct of BU members outside of the workplace that they shouldn’t negotiate to increase social distancing at work.
From the beginning, NATCA was crystal clear that their number one priority was the health and safety of its members. They negotiate working conditions. They do not negotiate activities outside of work. Any statement about what a member does or does not do outside of work is irrelevant to negotiations related to coronavirus related working conditions.
When NY shutdown on March 20, daily cases were ~2700 and rising. Currently, the 3 most populous states (CA, FL, TX) are at least double those levels and AZ is in a similar situation with a lower population. The argument that increased testing is the cause does not hold water when considering that the positivity rate is increasing.
The impact of having COVID-19 is much greater than most people realize even for young adults (Source:
Link). Also, scroll to the bottom
Link and 20-50% of patients face health challenges after discharge.
Does anyone really think that ALL BU employees should risk their health and that of their families so a few trainees can get raises 6-12 months sooner? If you do, I pose that it’s a very selfish stance to take. There’s nothing wrong with being that selfish, just be honest about your motivations.
The other argument being thrown out is that trainees need to return to prevent furloughs. First, this is a national health emergency. It’s unlikely the government will furlough unless it’s a last resort. Further, safety is priority one. I’d argue that a potential hit to pay should take a back seat to the safety of BU employees.
Acknowledging the very real threat the virus poses to everyone’s health, wearing masks and social distancing to prevent the spread of the virus being a matter of opinion have become a very real impediment to safely opening the economy. It’s really too bad. If everyone were taking the threat seriously, the current surges would be much lower and return to normal would likely come sooner than later.