ATC study

jtthompson25

Member
Messages
14
Hello, I am a former military and FAA controller, and current graduate student conducting a qualitative study titled "Examining How the Air Traffic Control Staffing Levels and Hiring Practices Have Affected the Outlook of the Profession" for my dissertation. The study will seek to answer the following questions:
  • what factors (mandatory overtime, outdated equipment, stagnant pay, substandard transfer system, etc.) affect the retention and recruitment of controllers?
  • What specific threats to safety may arise from the current professional outlook for controllers?
  • What effect might the development of new technologies aiming to increase safety to an expanding NAS have on the retention and recruitment of controllers?
All participants will be anonymous, and no identifying data will be collected. Volunteers would supply their facility type (ARTCC, tower, up/down, TRACON) and level to help categorize the results. If interested, please respond in this thread or message me prior to 3/20/2026. The only requisite is that volunteers work for the FAA. Thank you very much for your time and consideration.
 
Hello, I am a former military and FAA controller, and current graduate student conducting a qualitative study titled "Examining How the Air Traffic Control Staffing Levels and Hiring Practices Have Affected the Outlook of the Profession" for my dissertation. The study will seek to answer the following questions: what factors (mandatory overtime, outdated equipment, stagnant pay, substandard transfer system, etc.) affect the retention and recruitment of controllers? What specific threats to safety may arise from the current professional outlook for controllers? What effect might the development of new technologies aiming to increase safety to an expanding NAS have on the retention and recruitment of controllers?
All participants will be anonymous, and no identifying data will be collected. Volunteers would supply their facility type (ARTCC, tower, up/down, TRACON) and level to help categorize the results. If interested, please respond in this thread or message me prior to 3/20/2026. The only requisite is that volunteers work for the FAA. Thank you very much for your time and consideration.
One thing you might not know about is a big wave happened in 2010? Someone else may remember better. But basically there was a large influx of candidates based on how many sports they played in high school. Im sure someone can link the info and lawsuits etc.
 
Pay. That’s all you need to know.
I know that that is a big issue and leads to a lot of the other issues. This dissertation will seek to use a qualitative approach as opposed to just the numbers involved as that has been done before (including for the CRWG). I hope to publish this study in a few aviation publications and maybe it can garner some attention towards the issues that result.

One thing you might not know about is a big wave happened in 2010? Someone else may remember better. But basically there was a large influx of candidates based on how many sports they played in high school. Im sure someone can link the info and lawsuits etc.
That sounds very interesting
 
I know that that is a big issue and leads to a lot of the other issues. This dissertation will seek to use a qualitative approach as opposed to just the numbers involved as that has been done before (including for the CRWG). I hope to publish this study in a few aviation publications and maybe it can garner some attention towards the issues that result.
CRWG has nothing to do with pay, only traffic count. Pay is the issue
 
ChatGPT can give you a decent jump start on your dissertation. Finding actual controllers to talk to you and not be ratted out will be hard. Here you go:

1. Factors Affecting Recruitment and Retention of Air Traffic Controllers​

Mandatory Overtime and Staffing Shortages​

Many controllers report persistent understaffing at facilities, which leads to mandatory overtime, six-day workweeks, and frequent schedule disruptions. This contributes to burnout, fatigue, and reduced job satisfaction. Some controllers state that the workload makes the profession less attractive to new hires and causes experienced controllers to retire early or leave for other opportunities.

Work-Life Balance and Scheduling​

Controllers often cite rotating schedules, short rest periods (“quick turns”), and unpredictable shift assignments as major deterrents. These schedules can strain family life and personal health, making the career difficult to sustain long term.

Pay Relative to Responsibility​

While controller salaries are considered good in many regions, some respondents feel that compensation has not kept pace with inflation, workload increases, and the responsibility associated with ensuring aviation safety. New hires in particular may feel the training period and lower initial pay make the career less appealing compared to other technical fields.

Training Pipeline and Washout Rates​

Some controllers believe the training process is lengthy, inconsistent across facilities, and vulnerable to staffing pressures. High washout rates and long certification timelines may discourage trainees and contribute to staffing shortages.

Transfer System Limitations​

Controllers frequently cite the difficulty of transferring between facilities as a major retention issue. Limited opportunities to move geographically can trap controllers in locations they do not want to live long term, leading some to leave the profession entirely.

Equipment and Infrastructure​

Controllers sometimes report working with aging equipment, outdated radar displays, or inefficient software systems. While modernization programs exist, the slow pace of implementation can create frustration and a perception that the system is lagging behind technological capabilities.

Public and Organizational Perception​

Some controllers feel that the public and policymakers underestimate the complexity and stress of the profession, which can affect morale and the perceived prestige of the job.


2. Potential Threats to Safety from the Current Professional Outlook​

Fatigue​

Controllers working frequent overtime or quick turnarounds may experience cognitive fatigue, which can affect attention, reaction time, and decision-making.

Reduced Experience Levels​

If large numbers of experienced controllers retire or leave while facilities rely heavily on trainees, the overall experience level in the workforce may decline, potentially affecting operational resilience.

Training Bottlenecks​

Staffing shortages may pressure facilities to train controllers faster or conduct training while already short-staffed, which can strain instructors and trainees.

Morale and Disengagement​

Low morale may lead to reduced engagement, decreased motivation, or increased burnout, which could indirectly affect operational vigilance.

Complexity of Airspace​

The continued growth in air traffic volume and airspace complexity requires sustained staffing and technological support. If staffing levels lag behind traffic growth, controllers may face increasing workload.


3. Impact of New Technologies on Recruitment and Retention​

Positive Effects​

Decision Support Tools
Advanced automation and decision-support systems could reduce workload by helping controllers predict conflicts, manage sequencing, and monitor traffic flows.

Remote Tower Technology
Remote tower systems may allow staffing flexibility and reduce the need for physical relocation, potentially improving work-life balance.

Improved Situational Awareness
Modern displays, data integration, and predictive tools could enhance situational awareness and reduce cognitive workload.

Staffing and Overtime​

  • “We’ve been short-staffed for years. Mandatory overtime has basically become the norm rather than the exception.”
  • “Six-day workweeks are common here, and it wears people down. You can only do that for so long before burnout sets in.”
  • “We’re constantly balancing traffic levels with staffing shortages, and it feels like we’re always one sick call away from being critically short.”

Fatigue and Scheduling​

  • “Quick turns between shifts make it hard to get meaningful sleep. It definitely affects how alert you feel on position.”
  • “The rotating schedule is one of the hardest parts of the job. It takes a toll on your health and family life.”
  • “Fatigue is real. You do your best to stay sharp, but the schedule makes it difficult.”

Transfer System​

  • “The transfer process is extremely restrictive. Some controllers stay stuck in locations they never intended to live long-term.”
  • “People leave the job because they can’t move closer to family. That’s a huge retention problem.”
  • “The inability to transfer freely makes the career feel like a geographic commitment for life.”

Pay and Career Outlook​

  • “The pay is decent, but when you factor in inflation and the responsibility of the job, it hasn’t kept up the way many expected.”
  • “For the level of stress and responsibility involved, many people feel compensation should reflect that more clearly.”
  • “The training period is long and uncertain, which can discourage some people from pursuing the career.”

Equipment and Technology​

  • “Some of the equipment we use feels outdated compared to what modern technology could provide.”
  • “We’re slowly modernizing, but the pace can feel frustratingly slow.”
  • “Better decision-support tools could help reduce workload during complex traffic scenarios.”

Morale​

  • “Most controllers take pride in the job, but morale can drop when staffing shortages persist year after year.”
  • “There’s a lot of institutional knowledge walking out the door with retirements.”

Training Challenges​

  • “Training takes years, and instructors are often already stretched thin.”
  • “When staffing is low, training becomes even harder because instructors are needed on the floor.”

You can completely remove the equipment and modernization shit as NO current controllers working actual planes give one iota of a fuck about that dumb shit. As long as the old shit works and is reliable, it can, will and should be used. Here is a good start, but I imagine you’ll have an uphill battle if you want to interview/ get anonymous feedback from this site.
 
ChatGPT can give you a decent jump start on your dissertation. Finding actual controllers to talk to you and not be ratted out will be hard. Here you go:

1. Factors Affecting Recruitment and Retention of Air Traffic Controllers​

Mandatory Overtime and Staffing Shortages​

Many controllers report persistent understaffing at facilities, which leads to mandatory overtime, six-day workweeks, and frequent schedule disruptions. This contributes to burnout, fatigue, and reduced job satisfaction. Some controllers state that the workload makes the profession less attractive to new hires and causes experienced controllers to retire early or leave for other opportunities.

Work-Life Balance and Scheduling​

Controllers often cite rotating schedules, short rest periods (“quick turns”), and unpredictable shift assignments as major deterrents. These schedules can strain family life and personal health, making the career difficult to sustain long term.

Pay Relative to Responsibility​

While controller salaries are considered good in many regions, some respondents feel that compensation has not kept pace with inflation, workload increases, and the responsibility associated with ensuring aviation safety. New hires in particular may feel the training period and lower initial pay make the career less appealing compared to other technical fields.

Training Pipeline and Washout Rates​

Some controllers believe the training process is lengthy, inconsistent across facilities, and vulnerable to staffing pressures. High washout rates and long certification timelines may discourage trainees and contribute to staffing shortages.

Transfer System Limitations​

Controllers frequently cite the difficulty of transferring between facilities as a major retention issue. Limited opportunities to move geographically can trap controllers in locations they do not want to live long term, leading some to leave the profession entirely.

Equipment and Infrastructure​

Controllers sometimes report working with aging equipment, outdated radar displays, or inefficient software systems. While modernization programs exist, the slow pace of implementation can create frustration and a perception that the system is lagging behind technological capabilities.

Public and Organizational Perception​

Some controllers feel that the public and policymakers underestimate the complexity and stress of the profession, which can affect morale and the perceived prestige of the job.


2. Potential Threats to Safety from the Current Professional Outlook​

Fatigue​

Controllers working frequent overtime or quick turnarounds may experience cognitive fatigue, which can affect attention, reaction time, and decision-making.

Reduced Experience Levels​

If large numbers of experienced controllers retire or leave while facilities rely heavily on trainees, the overall experience level in the workforce may decline, potentially affecting operational resilience.

Training Bottlenecks​

Staffing shortages may pressure facilities to train controllers faster or conduct training while already short-staffed, which can strain instructors and trainees.

Morale and Disengagement​

Low morale may lead to reduced engagement, decreased motivation, or increased burnout, which could indirectly affect operational vigilance.

Complexity of Airspace​

The continued growth in air traffic volume and airspace complexity requires sustained staffing and technological support. If staffing levels lag behind traffic growth, controllers may face increasing workload.


3. Impact of New Technologies on Recruitment and Retention​

Positive Effects​

Decision Support Tools
Advanced automation and decision-support systems could reduce workload by helping controllers predict conflicts, manage sequencing, and monitor traffic flows.

Remote Tower Technology
Remote tower systems may allow staffing flexibility and reduce the need for physical relocation, potentially improving work-life balance.

Improved Situational Awareness
Modern displays, data integration, and predictive tools could enhance situational awareness and reduce cognitive workload.

Staffing and Overtime​

  • “We’ve been short-staffed for years. Mandatory overtime has basically become the norm rather than the exception.”
  • “Six-day workweeks are common here, and it wears people down. You can only do that for so long before burnout sets in.”
  • “We’re constantly balancing traffic levels with staffing shortages, and it feels like we’re always one sick call away from being critically short.”

Fatigue and Scheduling​

  • “Quick turns between shifts make it hard to get meaningful sleep. It definitely affects how alert you feel on position.”
  • “The rotating schedule is one of the hardest parts of the job. It takes a toll on your health and family life.”
  • “Fatigue is real. You do your best to stay sharp, but the schedule makes it difficult.”

Transfer System​

  • “The transfer process is extremely restrictive. Some controllers stay stuck in locations they never intended to live long-term.”
  • “People leave the job because they can’t move closer to family. That’s a huge retention problem.”
  • “The inability to transfer freely makes the career feel like a geographic commitment for life.”

Pay and Career Outlook​

  • “The pay is decent, but when you factor in inflation and the responsibility of the job, it hasn’t kept up the way many expected.”
  • “For the level of stress and responsibility involved, many people feel compensation should reflect that more clearly.”
  • “The training period is long and uncertain, which can discourage some people from pursuing the career.”

Equipment and Technology​

  • “Some of the equipment we use feels outdated compared to what modern technology could provide.”
  • “We’re slowly modernizing, but the pace can feel frustratingly slow.”
  • “Better decision-support tools could help reduce workload during complex traffic scenarios.”

Morale​

  • “Most controllers take pride in the job, but morale can drop when staffing shortages persist year after year.”
  • “There’s a lot of institutional knowledge walking out the door with retirements.”

Training Challenges​

  • “Training takes years, and instructors are often already stretched thin.”
  • “When staffing is low, training becomes even harder because instructors are needed on the floor.”

You can completely remove the equipment and modernization shit as NO current controllers working actual planes give one iota of a fuck about that dumb shit. As long as the old shit works and is reliable, it can, will and should be used. Here is a good start, but I imagine you’ll have an uphill battle if you want to interview/ get anonymous feedback from this site.
I appreciate the info. Yeah I can understand the reluctance to participate given the NYT article last year. I was an FAA controller until last year and just hope that some of the retention information can be collected and disseminated.
 
***UPDATE***
Thank you to everyone who has responded. I am going to extend the survey period to 4/1/2026. Part of my application to begin this study was show exactly how this study would remain anonymous and it passed through the review board. I also have to prove that it remained anonymous after the survey. I assure all participants that no identifiable information will be collected. Thank you!
 
Hi everyone,

I just wanted to thank all of the participants that answered. I am going to continue to receive feedback until April 15th. Again, thank you to everyone who has participated!
 
Back
Top Bottom